some friends on my facebook
have begun to spark a conversation
about "The deception of Christian Rock Music"
or even Christian contemporary music.
now my heart is set that this music industry is in so many ways
fruitful, God-glorifying, and truthful.
admittedly, like all other musicians out there
no one musician or band is perfect in their music or theology.
yet we hear of all these fundamentalists who criticize Christian rock
because for some strange reason:
1) ALL rock artists do drugs
2) ALL rock artists have sex with many women
3) ALL rock artists party too hard
4) and my personal favourite, ROCK MUSIC IS FROM THE DEVIL.
my question to all of this is:
1) how many Christ-proclaiming artists have they observed to come to this conclusion?
2) how many Christ-proclaiming artists have they observed to come to this conclusion?
3) how many Christ-proclaiming artists have they observed to come to this conclusion?
4) where in the Bible did you read that?
then the topic of
"if your music is too heavy on the music (in terms of how much rhythm there is, etc)
then it muffles out the spiritual content, if any."
now this is where i begin to really sit and observe.
first of all, music was supposed to be observed
in such a manner that people were supposed to
dig up the lyrics, read them, observe them and let them soak in.
now we live in a world where we take the lyrics as they hear it
and it puts artists in a space that limits us.
if we insist that the lyrics must be easy to understand
then that means the singer must be EXTREMELY good at anunciating
and the lyrics must often times be simple, almost TOO simple.
to me, this is a bit of a problem, because things become repetitive
the worship music industry is an example of that.
this is not to say that worship music is lame or talentless
but let's face it, so many songs out there sound the same.
their purpose still stands, and i can still resonate with their lyrics
but it sometimes becomes dry when you hear 10 different worship songs
singing the same thing.
an example of a band that i believe steps outside this box is Oh, Sleeper.
great metalcore band that loves God.
their lyrics reflect it, surprisingly.
their last album "son of the morning"
comes off as controversial, if taken at the surface level.
but if you dig deep into the lyrics, the meaning behind the album cover
then you begin to find that the meaning behind it all is
"God is eternally victorious."
and let's face it, Jesus was an icon of controversy when He was on Earth.
but when the people began to really see Him for who He was,
then that's when things began to change inside of them.
secondly, David writes
"Sing a new song to Him;
play skillfully on the strings, with a joyful shout."
-psalms 33:3
with every Christian musician being so drastically different musically
because of the vast range of genres
we are to give our absolute best in the music we make.
in metal music, this calls for our best in playing guitars and drums. this demands creativity, which sometimes means adding to the music.
in rap music, this calls for our best in rhyme, flow, and beat. again, creativity.
there are obviously more examples, but they all ultimately demand
our utmost creativity and skill for God.
not just half-hearted pieces of "i'm-not-gonna-try" music.
now i do admit that we sometimes put music ABOVE God, which is
idolatry, very obviously.
but is that the fault of the musicians, or the listeners?
the same concepts go for every piece of God-inspired media.
seek God first and foremost, let His truth be your lyrical output
allow people to dig into the music. sometimes, surface messages will dry up
give your all and be creative into what you are playing.
if you can do more for the music you make, do more.
just my two cents.
POST-TRIP – FEBRUARY 26, 2012
7 hours ago

1 echoes:
Hey Simon!
Granted, all of your arguments are valid. One thing that I have come across is that while the music may be edifying and glorifying to God from your point of view, it can also be a stumbling block to others. I read a book about a guy who did leave the contemporary Christian movement. It was from a man who was into rock music before he was a Christian and did all of the things that you said that fundamentalists associate rock music with. I'll quote the book directly.
"Some Christians say that rock music has no effect on them physically but I can assure you that it affected me. I believe its physical hold came about because rock music was associated with every flagrant sin of the flesh I had committed and even a hint of that music was enough to stir up memories of those ungodly associations."
So inherently music is not sinful. However, "Therefore let us not pass judgment on one another any longer, but rather decide never to put a stumbling block or hindrance in the way of a brother," Romans 14:13 (ESV). Would you continue to play rock music despite your weaker brother?
Now my question to you, what would you do if all the worship leaders decided to go back to hymns and choir songs permanently due to conviction from God? You say that it's not about the music it's about the words, then would you leave the church? The lyrics to the hymnals are just as doctrinally correct as the Christian rock music that hide the correct doctrine behind metaphors and analogies. So what makes Christian rock music "better" than old school hymns?
Another question to you, where do you define the line where your enjoyment for the words, becomes enjoyment for the music? Are you doing your music because it makes you feel good, or are you worshiping to give God the glory? Where are you going to draw the line?
Post a Comment